Jeff Turner

My Thoughts Exactly

My Thoughts Exactly

about  |  speaking | videos

 

Recommend Me or
Buy Me A Beer 🙂

Copyright © 2008 - © 2026

  • About
    • My Photo Blog
  • Speaking
    • Speaking Videos
  • Family
  • Just Dug Up
  • Landing Pages
    • Humaneering
    • When AI Learned to Sound Human
    • AI Image Wizardry
    • Turner Family Darts
    • GG Darts

The Switch Is Still Off

November 18, 2026 By Jeff Turner Leave a Comment

A week after I joined Twitter in March of 2007, I asked a question: “Can you say anything meaningful in 140 characters?” I answered it in the same post. STOP CHILD SLAVERY, in capital letters, with a link to the cause I was working on. Two nights later, I went to bed still not sure I “got” Twitter.

I spent the next seventeen years trying to figure it out. My archive holds 53,881 posts, and 29,823 of them are replies to other people. In 2008, I posted 9,643 times, about 26 a day, and most of those were answers to someone else. Nearly everything I wrote there was addressed to a real human.

We respectfully argued about real estate and technology. And traded links and photos. And raised money for each other’s charities. It felt like a community. I learned from people I would never have met any other way, and some of them became real friends. Many of those people still are.

Then the conversation ended. The algorithms took over. The place no longer felt welcoming. And I kept posting for a long time before I admitted it.

Other People’s Twitter Replies

I was aggressive with my feed curation. I followed very few people and blocked freely, so my own feed stayed mostly civil.

My friends’ mentions were a different place. When someone I respected and followed shared a thought, their replies would become littered with attacks from strangers who had no interest in the idea itself. They didn’t want to debate the concepts. They came for the person. Disagreement slid into insult almost immediately, and the feed pushed the sharpest insult to the top.

I had seen this before. In April 2020, I left Facebook because I kept reading friends’ posts and watching the worst behavior emerge in the comments, even among family. I wrote then that Twitter had the same problem but felt less personal. Near the end of that post, I told Facebook friends they could find me there.

By 2024, it felt personal on Twitter too. My downloaded archive shows it in a way I felt but couldn’t quantify then. In 2021, I replied to other people 933 times, nearly two of every three things I posted. In 2024, I replied 354 times, about two in five. I was still sharing photos and articles. But I was “talking” with far fewer people.

March 2007
A reply. Each line stands for about 38 of them, drawn from the center to someone else on Twitter/X.
A post to no one in particular. Originals and reposts. They leave the center and land nowhere.
The red. A conceptual illustration of what crept in: a few points at the far ends of the reply lines in 2014, then more of them, encroaching every year. Not data-driven.

Line and dot counts follow the @jeffturner archive, March 11, 2007 to November 18, 2024: 53,881 posts. For 2021 through 2024, replies count only replies to other people. Earlier years include a small number of self-replies.

About Humans Who Actually Can And Will

The months around the 2024 election were the worst I had ever experienced. People on every side did real damage to each other there, and frankly, I wanted no part of it. I’m open to changing my mind about most things. But nobody changes their mind while being called names.

On November 15, 2024, I shared a line from Rands, who described debate as a tricky act between two humans who can “speak, listen, understand, and possibly evolve.” He hinted he might not be on the platform much longer. Three days later, I posted a picture of a switch set to OFF, with no caption or explanation, and left.

Rereading Rand’s tweet now, the word “can” jumps out at me. Debate depends on the ability to do those four things. By the end of 2024, Twitter had become a place where that almost never happened, and trying harder wasn’t gonna change that. I doubt it’s better today. What I’ve read indicates it’s not.

I’m Still Looking For A Bigger Driveway

twitter

In September 2020, I spent two hours in the driveway of a neighbor’s house in a robust, respectful political argument. We found plenty of common ground and left as better friends than when we started. I tweeted about it and wrote that I needed more of that.

I still do. Two years after I turned off the switch on the platform formerly known as Twitter, what I miss most is the hope that public conversation, public debate, could work that way, with strangers, at scale. That hope got attacked away. If you’ve ever watched someone you respect get personally attacked in their replies (not debating their ideas, but attacking them for their looks, their intelligence, their mental health, their identity, their age, or their political affiliation, etc.), then you know what I mean.

I haven’t found that digital driveway yet. Not at scale, anyway. And given where AI is taking us, I’m not sure I ever will.


Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn

Like this:

Like Loading…

Related

Filed Under: Commentary

Add your voice... Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Loading Comments...
%d